Is Lye in Soap Bad? The Truth About Real & Handmade Soap

Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. If you click through and make a purchase, I may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you. I only recommend products I’ve personally used or believe will add value to your creative projects.

There’s one ingredient that always sparks debate when people first learn about handmade soap: lye.

It sounds scary — like something out of a high school chemistry lab. But here’s the secret soapmakers have known for centuries: lye isn’t bad for you when used correctly. In fact, it’s what turns oils into real soap.

If you’ve ever wondered “is lye in soap bad?” or “why does handmade soap feel different than store-bought bars?”, grab a cup of tea and let’s break down the real chemistry behind the bubbles.

⚗️ What Does Lye Do in Soap?

All real soap — whether cold process, hot process, or even melt-and-pour — starts with lye, also known as sodium hydroxide (for bar soap) or potassium hydroxide (for liquid soap).

When lye meets oils or fats, it triggers a chemical reaction called saponification. That’s a fancy way of saying “turns into soap.”

By the end of this reaction, there’s no active lye left — it’s completely neutralized. What’s left behind are two natural creations:

• Soap, which gently lifts away dirt and oil.

• Glycerin, a humectant that helps skin stay soft and moisturized.

So no, lye soap isn’t dangerous. It’s just real soap — the kind your great-grandparents used before detergents took over the shelves.

🔥 Hot Process vs. ❄️ Cold Process: Which Soap Is Safer?

Both hot process and cold process soap start with the same basic chemistry, but the timing is what makes them different.

Method	What Happens	Why It Matters
Cold Process Soap	Lye and oils mix and slowly turn into soap over 24–48 hours, then cure for 4–6 weeks.	The reaction continues after you pour, so the soap needs time to finish saponifying.
Hot Process Soap	The mixture is cooked until saponification finishes in the pot.	Once cooled, it’s fully saponified — no active lye left, making it ready to use sooner.

If you’re nervous about lye in soap, hot process soap is your comfort zone. It’s already fully reacted before you pour it into molds, meaning no active lye remains.

Plus, the rustic texture of hot process bars has a cozy, old-world charm — the kind of bar you’d imagine curing on a wooden shelf in a farmhouse kitchen.

🧴 Common Soap Myths (and the Real Chemistry Behind Them)

There’s a lot of misinformation about natural soap, melt and pour bases, and those “beauty bars” at the store. Let’s sort out the facts.

Myth	Truth
“Lye is bad for your skin.”	Not true. The lye disappears during saponification, leaving behind only gentle soap and moisturizing glycerin.
“Melt and pour soap doesn’t use lye.”	False. The base was originally made using lye — you’re just skipping the chemistry step.
“If it bubbles, it’s soap.”	Not necessarily. Most commercial bars are actually syndet bars (synthetic detergent bars). They clean with surfactants, not real soap.
“All soap is drying.”	Handmade soap keeps its natural glycerin and nourishing oils, so it’s usually less drying than detergent-based cleansers.
“Store-bought soap and handmade soap are the same.”	Nope. Big brands remove glycerin and add foaming agents. Legally, most can’t even call their product “soap” — that’s why you see “beauty bar” or “cleansing bar.”

So when you see a label that actually says soap, it’s likely made the traditional way — with lye and fats, not synthetic fillers.

🫧 Why Handmade Soap Doesn’t Lather Like Store-Bought Bars

One of the biggest questions I hear is: “Why doesn’t my handmade soap make tons of bubbles?”

Here’s the truth — bubbles don’t equal clean.

1. No synthetic foaming agents. Store soaps use surfactants like sodium lauryl sulfate for instant foam. Natural soap relies on the fatty acids from oils like coconut, olive, and castor for lather.

2. Different oils, different bubbles. Coconut oil makes fluffy bubbles; olive oil makes small, creamy ones. Each soap recipe balances cleansing and conditioning.

3. Water hardness affects lather. Hard water can reduce visible bubbles — but the soap still cleans effectively.

4. Real soap nourishes instead of stripping. A little less foam means a lot more moisture. Once your skin adjusts, you’ll notice it feels soft and balanced, not squeaky dry.

👉 So if your bar feels mild and creamy rather than bubbly and squeaky — that’s a good sign.

💛 Why Handmade Soap Is Better for Skin (and the Planet)

There are endless reasons people fall in love with handmade soap, but here are my top five:

1. It’s Real Soap.No detergents, no synthetic fragrances (unless you want them). Just oils, lye, and nature doing what it does best.

2. It Keeps Its Glycerin. Glycerin draws moisture to the skin — commercial brands strip it out to sell in lotions. Handmade soap keeps it where it belongs.

3. It’s Customizable. Want goat milk, oatmeal, or chamomile? You can make it. Prefer vegan? Easy. Want to infuse your own herbs? Even better.

4. It’s Gentle and Sustainable. Real soap biodegrades quickly, uses fewer harsh chemicals, and supports small makers rather than mass production.

5. It’s Made with Intention. Every bar tells a story — from the oils chosen to the herbs steeped in them. There’s craftsmanship in every swirl.

When you support handmade soapmakers, you’re choosing quality, transparency, and a product made by human hands — not factory machines.

🌿 The Real Truth About Lye and Handmade Soap

So, is lye in soap bad for you?

Absolutely not — it’s simply part of the chemistry that creates soap. Without lye, you’d just have oil and water (and a slimy mess).

When properly handled, lye does its job, disappears completely, and leaves behind the gentle cleanser our ancestors trusted for generations.

If you’re curious but cautious, start with a hot process soap — it’s fully saponified, safe to use right away, and still loaded with all the skin-loving benefits of traditional soap.

Because at the end of the day, real soap is honest soap — and handmade will always beat mass-produced.

Trying is good. Not trying is bad. 😉

✨ Ready to Try the Difference?

Experience the gentleness of Rooted N Red’s Hot Process Handmade Soaps — safe, moisturizing, and crafted with care (and yes, real lye chemistry done right).

Curious to learn more about how handmade soap is made or what goes into it?

Explore Rooted N Red’s Hot Process Handmade Soaps, read about our Natural Ingredients,  or dive into the Rooted in Curiosity blog series.

You can also visit About Rooted N Red to learn why I started this small-batch journey.

References:

• FDA – What is “Soap”? 

• Britannica – Saponification: The Chemistry of Soapmaking